1. Qhov no

Tobias Mittmann / www.youthphotos.eu, CC-daim ntawv tso cai(ntawm nc)

Txoj kev luv luv ntawm cov xovxwm tawm ntawm cov npe uas txhawj xeeb txog zaum (UCS):

"Yield yog tsis yog tus thawj qhia kom ua zoo luj xyuas rau tag nrho nyhuv genetic engineering tau muaj rau ntawm cov qoob loo yields in relation to lwm tus yees agricultural. Nws rov los xyuas dua ob teb kawm kev tshawb fawb ntawm cov pob kws thiab taum pauv, Tus ob lub txhob kaw engineered rau cov zaub mov thiab pub qoob loo zus nyob rau hauv lub tebchaws United States. Raws li cov kev tshawb fawb, lub UCS qhia xaus lus tias txhob kaw engineering tiv herbicide-thaiv taum pauv thiab tiv herbicide-thaiv pob kws twb tsis si yields. Kab-resistant pob kws, meanwhile, khees me ntsis lawm lawm yields marginally xwb. Qhov nce no hauv yields rau ob cov qoob loo dhau tus xeem 13 xyoo, daim ntawv nrhiav tau, muaj kev lom zem ntau vim tsoos qe los txhim kho rau txoj agricultural.”

Tau qhov twg los:
Gurian-Jocelyn Sherman, D. (2009) Yog koj tsis Yield, Ntsuam tau cov ntawv uas muaj tej qoob loo Engineered txhob kaw, Npe ot Concerned zaum pp (Daim ntawv hais qhia) – nrhiav ntawm no tseem cia nrog rau lub website.

 

2. Txoj kev uas qhov kev soj ntsuam PRRI

Kev tshawb fawb los ntawm Brookes & Barfoot, 2009, qhia piv tau sib txawv: Ntxiv cov qoob loo ntau lawm tsob ntawm positive yield los ntawm biotech sijhawm 1996-2006 (lab tonnes) – saib http://www.pgeconomics.co.uk/ pdf/UCSresponseapr2009.pdf

  1. Daim ntawv deals tsuas nrog rau ob qho loj cov qoob loo: Pobkws thiab taum hwv, yog tsis muaj kuj mus rau tag nrho cov qoob loo GM sweeping cov lus xaus. Lwm cov qoob loo xws li cov paj rwb thiab ua ib tug txawv oilseed txhom tsoob, zoo li daim duab, Nws yog Resolution caiv txoj kev ntsuam xyuas rau ob cov qoob loo thiab ces xaus rau tag nrho cov qoob loo GM.
  2. Cov qoob loo GM – tsawg thaum hauv paus – tsis tau tsim kom yield per se (ua lub cim ob ntawm GM kua yuav uas li no). Tus thawj GM qoob loo cim muaj nyuam nraaj txo yield losses nroj thiab kab – thiab yog li qhov xwm ntawm tus tswv teb economic, thiab Cov cog muaj lawm fulfilled kom zoo thiab kev kawm tshwm tag. UCS misleads tus nyeem ntawv los pom qhov tsis txawv cov views ntawm yield ob.
  3. GM qoob loo tau kuj nraaj txo kev siv herbicide (los yog ua rau nws tau ua hauj lwm ceev kom muaj environmentally ntau benign sawv daws yuav) thiab lawv pab txo tau cov tshuaj tua kab. Nws yog Resolution los UCS tsis tau pav tau cov lus tseeb.
  4. Cov qoob loo GM muaj ib tug pov thawj zoo txhob nyob rau tus hneev taw Conference kev muab siab kho siab ntau lawm ua liaj/teb (tsis tillage, neej zoo dua rau cov-phiaj kab thiab lwm yam.). Nws yog Resolution raws UCS daim ntawv qhia rau cov uas muaj cov teebmeem zoo raws "kev agricultural".

Nrhiav kev txhawb ntxiv thiab kev pab rau peb tshawb pom hauv no PDF:
NUG FORCE: Ua GM cov qoob loo tsis tsim ntau yield? Saib saib tshab web version